Grasping the Invisible. An Approach to Frontier Dynamics between Thrace and Macedonia through Digital Numismatics and Archaeology

Abstract

Digital numismatics is a rapidly developing field that lays a promising foundation for combined material cross-studies. In the course ofresearch of the project Measuring Ancient Thrace in this field, a new approach towards frontier studies between Thrace and Macedonia and generally any region with abundant enough coin circulation has emerged. It is a methodology that is yet to be applied in two comparative case studies and thus a theoretical proposal. The main aspect of it is that the digital numismatic perspective is the fundamental complementary factor to enhancing already existing methods

References:

Balabanov, P., Petrova, S. (2002). Dovelt, Deultum, Develt. – In: Rimski i Rannovizantiyski Gradove v Balgariya. Roman and Early Byzantine Cities in Bulgaria. Studies in Memory of Prof. Teofil Ivanov 1,1 (ed. R. Ivanov). Sofia, 237-250.

Delev, P. (2014). Istoriya na plemenata v Yugozapadna Trakiya prez I hil. pr. Hr.. A History of the Tribes of South-western Thrace in the First Millenium B.C. Sofia.

Grozdanova, L. (2021). Digitalna numizmatika – inovativni perspektivi kam traditsionen izvor – In: Back to the Sources. In Memory of the Editors of “Sources for the Ancient History and Geography of Thrace and Macedonia”, on the Occasion of the 70th Anniversary from the Publication of the Second Extended Version in 1949. Part 2: Archaeology and Numismatics, Jubilaeus VIII (P. Delev, D. Boteva-Boyanova, L. Grozdanova). Sofia, 63-70.

Grozdanova, L. (forthcoming). From Deutum to DigiDeultum: the Concept – In: Vazobnovyavane Na Arheologicheskite Prouchvaniya v Deultum Ot 2003 g. Nauchna Konferentsiya. Archaeologia Bulgarica Supplement. Sofia.

Kolev, F. (2020). Selishtna sistema v dolinata na Sredna Struma prez elinisticheskata epoha (IV v. pr. Hr. – sredata na II v. pr. Hr.) – In: Problemi i izsledvaniya na trakiyskata kultura (ed. M. Tonkova, G. Nehrizov). Kazanlak, 185-223.

Mitrev, G. (2012). Dolinata na Struma prez Antichnostta. Plemena i selishta. Asenovgrad.

Tachev, Y. (2018). Monetosecheneto na Anhialos (Coinage of Anchialos). Sofia.

Topalov, S. (1995). Mesambriya Pontika. Prinosi kam prouchvane monetosechenieto na grada V - v. pr. n. e.. Sofia.

Vagalinski, L. (2022). Herakleya Sintika. Istoriya chrez arheologiya, Archaeologia Bulgarica Supplement 4. Sofia.

Vagalinski, L., Cholakov, I., Kecheva, N. (2017). Izdirvane na arheologicheski obekti v obshtina Petrich – In: Arheologicheski Otkritiya i Razkopki Prez 2016 (ed. L. Vagalinski). Sofia, 690-691.

Alexandrova, S. (2020). Roman Temporary Military Camp from the 2nd Century BC near the Village of Polenitsa, Sandanski Municipality, SW Bulgaria. – Archaeologia Bulgarica, No. XXIV, 2, 41–77.

Belfiori, F. (2020). Roman Colonization, Sanctuaries and Cult in the Middle-Adriatic Area between the 3rd and 2nd Centuries BC. – In: Boundaries in Archaeology: Economy, Sacred Places, Cultural Influences in the Ionian and Adriatic Areas, Panel 7.3, Archaeology and Economy in the Ancient World 39 (eds. E. Giorgi, G. Lepore, A. Gamberini). Heidelberg, 5–23.

Betsiou, A. (2016). Reconsidering the Interpretation and Dating of Ancient Coins: the Case of Bronze Coins from Dodona in the Name of Menedemos Argeades. – Gephyra, No. 13, 127-148.

Boteva, D. (2020). The Historical Context of the Bronze Statue of Septimius Severus from the Roman Colony of Deultum. – Archaeologia Bulgarica XXIV, 1, 23-32.

Bursche, A. (2002). Circulation of Roman Coinage in Northern Europe in Late Antiquity. – Histoire & Mesure, No. XVII, 121–141.

Bursche, A. (2008). Function of Roman coins in Barbaricum of Later Antiquity: An Anthropological Essay. – In: Roman Coins Outside the Empire. Ways and Phases, Contexts and Functions. Proceedings of the ESF/SCH Exploratory Workshop, Radziwłł Palace, Nieborów (Poland), 3-6 September 2005. (eds. A. Bursche, R. Ciołek, R. Wolters). Wetteren, 395-416.

Calomino, D., Bologna, F., Wilson, P., Donnelly, M., Williams, M. (2023). Imaging Hadrian in Britain between Coinage and Sculpture: A New Digital Approach to the Study of Roman Imperial Portraiture. – Britannia, No. 54, 251-274.

Chatzinikolaou, K. (2010). Locating Sanctuaries in Upper Macedonia According to Archaeological Data. – Kernos. Revue internationale et pluridisciplinaire de religion grecque antique, No. 23, 193-222.

Chausson, F., Galliano, G., Ferranti, F. (eds.). (2019). Claude: Lyon, 10 avant J.-C.-Rome, 54 après J.-C.: un empereur au destin singulier. Lyon.

Chyla, J.M. (2022). Tingitana Frontier Project – Polish-Moroccan exploration of the Roman limes in Morocco. https://archeowiesci.pl/en/tingitana-frontier-project-polish-moroccan-exploration-of-the-roman-limes-in-morocco/ (accessed 05.12.2022).

CN n.d.: CN, Corpus Nummorum Data Model. https://www.corpus-nummorum.eu/resources/database (accessed 29.06.2024).

Cope, S. N. (1980). The Statistical Analysis of Coin Weights by Computer and a Rationalized Method for Producing Histograms. – The Numismatic Chronicle, No.20 (140), 178-184.

Costa, K. da. (2011). Drawing the Line: An Archaeological Methodology for Detecting Roman Provincial Borders. – In: Frontiers in the Roman World. Proceedings of the Ninth Workshop of the International Network Impact of Empire (Durham, 16-19 April 2009), Impact of Empire 13 (ed. O. Hekster, T. Kaizer). Leiden, 49-60.

Dadaki, S., Koukouli-Chrysanthaki, Ch., Stampoulogou, M. (2014). Archaiologikos Chartis tou Dimou Sintikis. Archaeological Map of the Municipality Sintiki. – In: Dimos Sintikis. O horos kai i istoria tou. Gia ta 100 hronia apo tin apeleutherosi tis Sintikis (eds. E. Tsoykala, Ch. Koykoyli–Chrysanthakh, G. Tsaryoychas, G. Apshlidhs). Siderokastro, 163-176.

de Callataÿ, F. (2018). Overstrikes in the Greek world: an Overview on the Full Landscape and an Explanation for Punctual Occurrences with Silver Coinages. – Revue belge de numismatique et de sigillographie 164, 26-48.

del Hoyo, T. C., Antela-Bernárdez, B., Arrayás-Morales, I., Busquets-Artigas, S. (2011). The ‘Ultimate Frontier’: War, Terror and the Greek Poleis Between Mithridates and Rome. – In: Frontiers in the Roman World. Proceedings of the Ninth Workshop of the International Network Impact of Empire (Durham, 16-19 April 2009), Impact of Empire 13 (ed. O. Hekster, T. Kaizer). Leiden, 291-304.

Delev, P. (2015). From Koroupedion to the Beginning of the Third Mithridatic War (281–73 BCE). – In: A Companion to Ancient Thrace (ed. J. Valeva, E. Nankov, D. Graninger). Chichester, 59-74.

Deutsche Limeskommission (2007). Beiträge zum Welterbe Limes. Konrad Theiss Verlag. Stuttgart.

Draganov, D. (1991). The Countermarks of Moesia Inferior and Thrace. – Klio, No. 73.2, 495-509.

Draganov, D. (2005). Sylloge Nummorum Graecorum Bulgaria, Thrace & Moesia Inferior, Volume 1: Deultum. Ruse.

Draganov, D. (2007). The Coinage of Deultum. Sofia.

Duncan, G. L. (1981). Coin circulation on the Danubian limes of Dacia Ripensis, – In: Ancient Bulgaria. Papers Presented to the International Symposium on the Ancient History and Archaeology of Bulgaria, University of Nottingham 1981, 1. Nottingham, 165-176.

Dyson, S. L. (2014). The Creation of the Roman Frontier, Course Book. Princeton Legacy Library. Princeton, NJ.

Fachard, S. (2016). Modelling the territories of Attic demes: a computational approach. – In: The Archaeology of Greece and Rome. Studies in Honour of Anthony Snodgrass (ed. J. Bintliff, N. K. Rutter). Edinburgh, 192-222.

Fassbinder, J. W. E. (2009). Global survey of the frontiers of the Roman Empire in Southern Germany, UNESCO World Heritage Site. – ArcheoSciences. Revue d’archéométrie, No. 33 (Suppl.), 55-58.

Filipova, S., Ivanov, S. (2015). Numismatic data from the archaeological excavations at Heraclea Sintica located on the Hill of Kozhuh, Petrich Municipality, – In: Heraclea Sintica: From Hellenistic Polis to Roman Civitas (4th C. BC - 6th C. AD): Proceedings of a Conference At Petrich, Bulgaria, September 19-21, 2013, Papers of the American Research Center in Sofia (ed. L. Vagalinski, E. Nankov). Sofia, 168-227.

Gambash, G. (2015). Rome and provincial resistance, Routledge Monographs in Classical Studies. New York.

Găzdac, C. (2002). Monetary circulation and the abandonment of the auxiliary forts in Roman Dacia, – In: Limes 18. Proceedings of the 18th International Congress of Roman Frontier Studies Held in Amman, Jordan (September 2000) (ed. P. Freeman, J. Bennett, Z. T. Fiema, B. Hoffmann). Oxford, 737-756.

Gruber, E., Bransbourg, G., Heath, S., Meadows, A. (2014). Linking Roman Coins: Current Work at the American Numismatic Society. – In: Archaeology in the Digital Era: Papers from the 40th Annual Conference of Computer Applications and Quantitative Methods in Archaeology (CAA), Southampton, 26-29 March 2012 (ed. G. Earl, T. Sly, D. Wheatley, I. Romanowska, C. Papadopoulos, P. Murrieta-Flores, A. Chrysanthi) Amsterdam, 249-258.

Gruen, E. S. (1976). Rome and the Seleucids in the Aftermath of Pydna, – Chiron. Mitteilungen Der Kommission Für Alte Geschichte Und Epigraphik Des Deutschen Archäologischen Instituts, No. 6, 73-95.

Hofmann, K., Grunwald, S., Lang, F., Peter, U., Rösler, K., Rokohl, L., Schreiber, S., Tolle, K., Wigg-Wolf, D. (2019). Ding-Editionen. Vom archäologischen (Be-)Fund übers Corpus ins Netz, – E-Forschungsberichte des DAI, No. 2019 (Fasc.2), 1-12.

Howgego, C. J. (1985). Greek Imperial Countermarks: Studies in the Provincial Coinage of the Roman Empire. London.

Isaac, B. (1988). The Meaning of the Terms Limes and Limitanei. – The Journal of Roman Studies, No. 78, 125-147.

Ivanova-Anaplioti, H. (2023). Interaction and Problematics of the Bronze Coinage Minted for Apollonia Pontica at the Edge of the 4th towards the 3rd c. BC. – Bulgarian Numismatic Journal 1,1, 70-84.

Ivanova-Anaplioti, H. (forthcoming). Contact and demarcation patterns based on the excavation coins from Heraclea Sintica, season 2021. – In: Proceedings of the International conference “10th Joint Meeting of ECFN and Nomisma.org & the 2nd Bulgarian Numismatic Readings”, June 19th to 23rd, 2023, Sofia University St. Kliment Ohridski, Bulgarian Numismatic Journal Suppl. 1. Sofia.

Jurukova, J. (1973). Die Münzprägung von Deultum, Schriften zur Geschichte und Kultur der Antike, Griechisches Münzwerk. Berlin.

Karavas, J., Hanscam, E. (2023). The Lower Danube Limes: Recentring a Roman Frontier Province. – In: Roman Frontier Studies, The Roman Lower Danube Frontier, Innovations in Theory and Practice (ed. J. Karavas, E. Hanscam). Oxford, 1-12.

Katsari, C. (2008). The Monetization of Rome’s Frontier Provinces. – In: The Monetary Systems of the Greeks and Romans (ed. W. V. Harris). Oxford, 242-264.

Keresztes, P. (1970). The Constitutio Antoniniana and the Persecutions under Caracalla. – The American Journal of Philology, No. 91.4, 446-459.

Kolb, A. (2017). The importance of internal borders in the Roman Empire: Written sources and model cases. – Rome’s Internal Frontiers. Proceedings of the 2016 RAC Session in Rome, Zurich Studies in Archaeology Vol. 11 (ed. P. Della Casa, E. Deschler-Erb). Zürich, 5-12.

Lepore, G., Silani, M. (2021). Lo sviluppo di una conquista. Dalla fondazione della colonia di Sena Gallica all’organizzazione dell’ager. – Dialogues d’histoire ancienne, No. 23, 179-212.

Mann, J. C. (1974). The Frontiers of the Principate. – In: Aufstieg und Niedergang der Römischen Welt (ANRW). Teil 2 Principat. Band 1 Politische Geschichte (Allgemeines) (ed. H. Temporini). Rome, 508-533.

Martorelli, D., Bortolotti, M., Capris, M., Lutterotti, L., Maines, L., Pepponi, G., Gialanella, S. (2019). A combined experimental approach to the study of ancient coins and its application to the Venetian “sesino.” – Nuclear Instruments and Methods in Physics Research Section B: Beam Interactions with Materials and Atoms, No. 455, 108-113.

Meadows, A. (2021). Local Scripts on Archaic Coins: Distribution and Function, – In: The Early Greek Alphabets: Origin, Diffusion, Uses (ed. R. Parker, P. M. Steele). Oxford, 187-222.

Mitrev, G. (2003). Civitas Heracleotarum: Heracleia Sintica or the ancient city at the village of Rupite (Bulgaria). – Zeitschrift für Papyrologie und Epigraphik, No. 145, 263-271.

Mitrev, G. (2015). On the Borders and Urban Territory of Heraclea Sintica. – In: Heraclea Sintica: From Hellenistic Polis to Roman Civitas (4th C. BC – 6th C. AD): Proceedings of a Conference at Petrich, Bulgaria, September 19-21, 2013, Papers of the American Research Center in Sofia (ed. L. Vagalinski, E. Nankov). Sofia, 47-53.

Moisil, D. (2002). The Danube Limes and the Barbaricum (294-498 A.D.). – Histoire & mesure, No. XVII, 79-120.

Moschek, W. (2011). Der Römische Limes: eine Kultur- und Mentalitätsgeschichte. 3rd ed. Speyer.

Munteanu, L. (2017). Some considerations of the Roman coin finds in the hinterland of the provinces of Dacia and Moesia Inferior, – In: Proceedings of the XV International Numismatic Congress. Taormina 2015 (ed. M. C. Caltabiano) Rome, 925–929.

Munteanu, L. (2020). Some considerations on the coin finds in the sites of Roman Dacia, – In: Rome and Barbaricum: Contributions to the Archaeology and History of Interaction in European Protohistory. (ed. R.-G. Curcă, A. Rubel, R. P. Symonds, H.-U. Voß. Oxford, 85-114.

Munteanu, L., Honcu, Ș., Aparaschivei, D. (2021). On the Chronology of Roman Coins in Barbaricum. Denarii Finds from the Site of Schineni (Bacau County). – In: Migration and Identity in Eurasia: From Ancient Times to the Middle Ages. Editura Mega (ed. V. Cojocaru, A.-I. Pázsint). Cluj-Napoca, 139-165.

Munteanu, L., Vornicu, N. (2022). Contribuţii la problema imitaţiilor de denari romani imperiali din Moldova. Descoperirea monetară din necropola de la Dumitreștii Gălăţii (comuna Schitu Duca, judeţul Iași, România). – RAASI, No. 4, 257-266.

Nankov, E. (2015). In Search of a Founder and the Early Years of Heraclea Sintica. – In: Heraclea Sintica: From Hellenistic Polis to Roman Civitas (4th C. BC – 6th C. AD): Proceedings of a Conference at Petrich, Bulgaria, September 19-21, 2013, Papers of the American Research Center in Sofia (ed. L. Vagalinski, E. Nankov). Sofia, 7-35.

Pavlek, B., Winters, J., Morin, O. (2022). Standards and quantification of coin iconography: possibilities and challenges. – Digital Scholarship in the Humanities, No. 37, 202-217.

Peter, U. (2019). Von Mommsen zum Semantic Web: Perspektiven der vernetzten numismatischen Forschung – die Münzen der westlichen Schwarzmeerküste online, – In: Advances in Ancient Black Sea Studies: Historiography, Archaeology and Religion, Pontica et Mediterranea (ed. V. Cojocaru, D. Braund, T. Castelli, L. Grumeza, A.-I. Pázsint, L. Ruscu). Cluj-Napoca, 393-418.

Peter, U., Stolba, V. (2022). „Land ohne Grenzen“ – Thrakiens Münzprägung und Identität, – In: Thrace – Local Coinage and Regional Identity, Berlin Studies of the Ancient World (ed. U. Peter, V. Stolba). Berlin, 3-18.

Preshlenov, H. (2015). Deultum-Debeltos: Archaeological Excavation of the Street Spaces and Structures, 2004-13, – In: The Danubian Lands between the Black, Aegean and Adriatic Seas (7th Century BC - 10th Century AD) (ed. G. R. Tsetskhladze, A. Avram, J. Hargrave). Oxford, 395-402.

Sanz, I. D., Fiore, D. (2014). Style: Its Role in the Archaeology of Art, – In: Encyclopedia of Global Archaeology (ed. C. Smith). New York, 7104-7111.

Schallmayer, E. (2011). Der Limes: Geschichte einer Grenze. 3rd ed. München.

Schönert-Geiß, E. (1972). Die Münzprägung von Byzantion. Kaiserzeit, Schriften zur Geschichte und Kultur der Antike. Berlin.

Sommer, C. S. (2021). A European Project: The Frontiers of the Roman Empire – Protection and Communication of World Heritage in an International Context. – ICOMOS – Hefte des Deutschen Nationalkomitees, No. 79, 36-41.

Stek, T. D. (2017). The impact of Roman Expansion and Colonization on Ancient Italy in the Republican Period. From Diffusionism to Networks of Opportunity, – In: The Peoples of Ancient Italy (ed. G. D. Farney, G. Bradley). Berlin, 269–294.

Taş, E., Özdemir, A., Acar, S. (2022). SEM-EDS Analysis Used to Determine Value Changes in Ottoman Coins Based on Political Developments. – Mediterranean Archaeology and Archaeometry, No. 22.2, 35-50.

Universität Wien (n.d.a). Danube Limes Brand. Extension of the Danube Limes UNESCO World Heritage in the Lower Danube. http://danubelimesbrand.org/ (accessed 05.12.2022).

Universität Wien (n.d.b). Limes-Projekt. https://geschichtsforschung.univie.ac.at/forschung/abgeschlossene-projekte/limes-projekt/ (accessed 05.12.2022).

University of Southern Denmark (2024). Bulgarian-Greek border region. Borders Shaping Perceptions of European Societies (B-SHAPES) https://www.sdu.dk/en/forskning/forskningsenheder/samf/b-shapes/about/casestudies/bulgariangreek (accessed 30.01.2024).

Urbanus, J. (2022). Rare Boundary Marker. Archaeology Magazine, No. January/February 2022.

Utrecht University (2023). Constructing the Limes. Employing citizen science to understand borders and border systems from the Roman period until today. https://c-limes.nl/?lang=en (accessed 05.12.2022).

Vagalinski, L. (2017). Heraclea Sintica (Current Archaeological Chronology). – Acta Musei Tiberiopolitani 2, 89-95.

Wells, C. M. (1996). Profuit invitis te dominante capi: social and economic considerations on the Roman frontiers. – Journal of Roman Archaeology 9, 436-446.

Wells, P. S. (2005). Creating an Imperial Frontier: Archaeology of the Formation of Rome’s Danube Borderland. – Journal of Archaeological Research 13, 49-88.