From Macedonia to North Macedonia
how (not) to solve the Macedonian name dispute
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.60054/PEU.2018.5.145-156Keywords:
Macedonia, nation building, clashing historical narratives, name dispute solutionAbstract
In the early 1990’s Greece blocked the international recognition of the Republic of Macedonia under that name and is currently blocking accession of this country to NATO and EU demanding name changes which the government of Skopje refuses to adopt. The Macedonia name dispute is a clash over historical narratives and the right to claim origins of the Macedonian ethnic group and nation today and in the ancient past. For Greece, the key element is winning the argument over the legitimacy of ancient Macedon as a Greek state and not having the name Macedonia used by its northern neighbour. For the Republic, the intricacies of the ancient history are only instrumental to the recognition of the country under its constitutional name and the unblocking of the Euro-Atlantic integration. An Agreement between the governments of the two countries has been reached to “solve” the dispute. In the agreement Macedonia gives up on the name Macedonia and leaves ancient history of Macedon as a Greek patrimony. A political solution was reached with the Macedonian government essentially giving up its position in the dispute for the Euro-Atlantic integration. EU conditionality has worked in the case of Macedonia although the internal stability might have been endangered for a long period as a result.
References
Abizadeh Arash. (2004). Historical Truth, National Myths and Liberal Democracy: On the Coherence of Liberal Nationalism. The Journal of Political Philosophy, 12(3).
Bourdieu, P. (1989). Social Space and Symbolic Power. Sociological Theory, 7(1).
Floudas Demetrius Andreas. (1996). A Name for a Conflict or a Conflict for a Name? An Analysis of Greece's Dispute with FYROM. Journal of Political and Military Sociology, 24.
Froomkin, A. M. (2004). When We Say USTM, We Mean It! Houston Law Review, 41(3), 840- 41.
Janev, I. (1999). Legal Aspects of the use of a Provisional Name for Macedonia in the United Nations System. American Journal of International Law, 93(1), 155-160.
Kitromilides, P. (1983). The Enlightenment East and West: A Comparative Perspective on the Ideological Origins of the Balkan Political Traditions. Canadian Review of Studies in Nationalism, 10(1), 51-70.
Kofos Evangelos. (2005). The Controversy over the Terms ‘Macedonians’ and ‘Macedonian’: A Probable Exit Scenario. Southeast European and Black Sea Studies, 5(1).
Kofos Evangelos. (2009). The Current Macedonian Issue between Athens and Skopje: Is there an Option for a Breakthrough? (ELIAMEP Thesis No. 3).
Reimer Larry. (1995). Macedonia: Cultural Right or Cultural Appropriation? University of Toronto Faculty of Law Review, 53.
Roudometof Victor. (1996). Nationalism and Identity Politics in the Balkans: Greece and the Macedonian Question. Journal of Modern Greek Studies, 14(2).
Sarakinski Vojislav and Dalibor Jovanovski. (2016). ‘Textbook truths’ and political dilemmas: The image of Ancent Macedonia in 19th century Greek historiography. Topical Problems in Modern Historical Science, N.1. University of Primorska and Krakow University.
Tziampiris Aristotle. (2012). The Macedonian name dispute and European Union accession. Southeast European and Black Sea Studies, 12(1).
Vangeli Anastas. (2011). Nation-building ancient Macedonian style: the origins and the effects of the so-called antiquization in Macedonia. Nationalities Papers, 39(1).
Zahariadis Nikolaos. (1996). Greek Policy Toward the Former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia. Journal of Modern Greek Studies, 14(2), 303-328.
Books
Anderson, B. (1991). Imagined Communities. Verso.
Apostolski, M., Zografski, D., Stoyanovski, A., & Todorovski, G. (Eds.). (1979). A History of the Macedonian People. Macedonian Review.
Calhoun, C. (1997). Nationalism. Open University Press.
Daskalovski Zhidas. (2005). Minorities in Nation-Building Processes. Friedrich Ebert Stiftung.
Featherstone M. (1990). Global Culture: Nationalism, Globalization and Modernity. Sage.
Henkin Louis, Pugh, R. C., Schachter, O., & Smit, H. (1993). International Law: Cases and Materials (3rd ed.). Westgroup.
Jelavich, B. (1983). History of the Balkans. Eighteenth and Nineteenth Century. Cambridge University Press.
Lozanovska, J. (2009). The Name Issue Exposing and deconstructing the Greek arguments. Evro Balkan.
Kiselinovski Stojan. (Ed.). (2000). Makedonski Istoriski Recnik. Institut za nacionalna istorija.
Klimovski Savo. (1994). Ustavno Pravo. Union Trade.
Michas, T. (2002). The Unholy Alliance: Greece and Milosevic's Serbia during the 1990s. Texas A & M University Press.
Smith, A.D. (1999). Myths and Memories of the Nation. University Press.
Tashkovski, D. (1976). The Macedonian Nation. Nasha Kniga.
Article in edited volume
Brunnbauer, U. (2005). “Ancient Nationhood and the Struggle for Statehood: Historiographic Myths in the Republic of Macedonia.” In P. Kolstø (Ed.), Myths and Boundaries in South-Eastern Europe. C. Hurst.
Craven, M. C. R. (1999). “What's in a Name? The Former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia and Issues of Statehood.” In D. R. Rothwell, S. Kaye, A. Akhtarkhavari, & R. Davis (Eds.), International Law: Cases and Materials with Australian Perspectives.
Kofos Evangelos. (2001). «Greek Policy Considerations Over FYROM Independence and Recognition.» In J. Pettifer (Ed.), The New Macedonian Question (pp. 226-263). Palgrave.
Kofos Evangelos. (2010). “Prospects for resolving the name issue.” NATO Parliamentary Assembly’s Rose-Roth Seminar, http://www.macedonian-heritage.gr/Contributions/Prospects%20for
MKD.mk. (2017, December 25). Macedonians and Albanians in agreement to have a referendum to solve the problem with the name.
Mircev, D. (2001). “Engineering the Foreign Policy of a New Independent State: The Case of Macedonia, 1990-96.” In J. Pettifer (Ed.), The New Macedonian Question. Palgrave-MacMillan.
Panov Mitko B. (2008). “Macedonia and the Slavs(from the middle of the VI century to the middle of IX century).” In A. Shukarova et al., History of the Macedonian People. Institute of National History.
Newspaper articles
Bakoyannis Dora. (2008, March 31). The view from Athens. International Herald Tribune.
Balkan Insight. (2009, August 23). Greek Naming Dispute Reply "Not Positive".
Business Insider. (2015, December 16). Macedonia may change its name to settle a decades-long dispute with Greece.
Balkan Open Report. (2013, September 13). UN Mediator: Gaps Remain on Greece-Macedonia Name Deal.
Ekathimerini. (2018, February 2). Skopje officials will not compromise ‘Macedonian’ nationality.
Ekathimerini. (2018, February 1). Greece sees breakthrough soon in FYROM name impasse.
EurActiv. (2011, March 1). Macedonia to hold referendum on new name.
EurActiv. (2013, April 16). UN mediator tables new proposal for Macedonia's name.
Greek Reporter. (2016, October 22). President Says Will Defend Greek Identity of Macedonia: “Nobody Has the Right to Claim Things That Don’t Belong to Them”.
Greek Reporter. (2018, January 30). Poll: 59% of Greeks Oppose “Macedonia” in FYROM Name.
Loizides Neophytos. (2018, January 30). Who gets to use the name ‘Macedonia’? A decades-old row still to be resolved. The Conversation.
Reuters. (2018, January 14). Majority of Greeks against use of "Macedonia" in any solution to name dispute: poll.
Thema News. (2016, October 18). Greek President sends strong message to Turkey and FYROM.
International agreements and official documents
General Assembly Resolution 2625 (XXV) of 24 October. (1970).
Interim Accord (with related letters and translations of the Interim Accord in the Languages of the Contracting Parties), signed in New York 13 September 1995; entered into force 13 October 1995. (1995). 1891 U.N.T.S. I-32193; 34 I.L.M. 1461.
International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (ICCPR), Article 1. (n.d.).
Ministry of Foreign Affairs of Greece. (2016). The FYROM name issue. http://www.mfa.gr/www.mfa.gr/en-US/Policy/Geographic+Regions/
Vienna Convention on the Representation of States in their Relations with International Organizations of a Universal Character. (1975, March 14). UN Doc. A/CONF. 67/16.
